Anita Knutson: Know All About Her, Who Is She?
This is a story about a real person. A young woman with a whole life ahead of her. A girl who played violin, wrote a book at thirteen, and wanted to spend her days teaching children. This is not just a crime story. It is Anita Knutson’s story — and she deserves to be remembered as more than a case number.
Quick Bio Facts Table
| Detail | Info |
|---|---|
| Full Name | Anita May Knutson |
| Date of Birth | September 22, 1988 |
| Birthplace | Orange County, California |
| Adopted | February 1989 (at 5 months old) |
| Adoptive Parents | Gordon and Sharon (Fellows) Knutson |
| Siblings | 10 adopted siblings (including Anna and Daniel) |
| Nationality | American |
| Schools Attended | Glenknoll Elementary, Bernardo Yorba Middle School, Esperanza High School (CA), Velva High School (ND) |
| College | Minot State University |
| Major | Elementary Education |
| Jobs | Fairfield Inn hotel, Vanity store (Dakota Square Mall) |
| Talents | Violin, piano, soccer, published author |
| Date of Death | June 3, 2007 (found June 4) |
| Age at Death | 18 years old |
| Location of Murder | Apartment at 2420 4th St NW, Minot, North Dakota |
| Case Status (2026) | Unsolved |
A California Baby Who Found Home in the Midwest
Anita Knutson came into the world on September 22, 1988, in Orange County, California. She never knew her birth parents. But just five months after she was born, a couple named Gordon and Sharon Knutson opened their door — and their hearts — and welcomed her in.
The Knutson family was a big, beautiful, busy household. Eleven children in total. Some might imagine that getting lost in a crowd that size would be easy. For Anita, it was the opposite. She was loved fiercely and loved fiercely in return. She called her mother often — daily, in fact, even after she moved out for college.
They lived in Anaheim, California for most of Anita’s childhood. She went to Glenknoll Elementary and then Bernardo Yorba Middle School. The family later moved to Butte, North Dakota in 2002, when Anita was in high school. A cross-country move is hard for most teenagers. Anita handled it with the same quiet strength she brought to everything else.
The Girl Who Did Everything
At Bernardo Yorba Middle School in California, Anita Knutson did something remarkable. She wrote and published a book — in eighth grade. Most thirteen-year-olds are focused on lunch and weekends. Anita was putting her thoughts into print.
When the family moved to North Dakota, she enrolled at Velva High School. She did not shrink into the background. She joined the Family, Career and Community Leaders of America (FCCLA) and earned both state and national recognition for her work on drug awareness. She served as Vice President of the Future Business Leaders of America (FBLA) in her junior year. She was also selected for the Girls State program — a competitive leadership experience only a select few students are chosen for.
Outside of school, she played soccer, learned the violin and the piano, and maintained the kind of grades that earned her a graduation with honors in 2006.
She was not just smart. She was kind. She was the kind of person who made a room feel warmer just by walking into it.
Chasing a Dream in Minot
After graduating, Anita Knutson packed up and headed to Minot State University. She wanted to become an elementary school teacher. That choice tells you everything about who she was — she wanted to spend her life helping children grow.
To pay her way through school, she worked two jobs. She cleaned rooms at the Fairfield Inn and worked at a clothing store called Vanity inside the Dakota Square Mall. She was 18, working hard, studying hard, and building the beginning of a life she was excited about.
She shared a small two-bedroom apartment with a girl she knew from home — Nichole Thomas, who would later become known as Nichole Rice.
The Relationship That Turned Dangerous
From the outside, two girls from the same small town moving to university together sounds like a good plan. Inside that apartment, though, things were not good. Not even close.
Witnesses described the dynamic between Anita Knutson and Nichole as tense, sour, and getting worse. There were fights about an alarm clock going off behind a locked bedroom door. There were arguments about a fish tank — Anita turned off the filter repeatedly because the noise bothered her, and eventually the fish died. There were threatening text messages. There was one instance where a friend heard Nichole tell Anita, “One way or another, I’m going to get you out of this house.”
Anita was frightened. Her mother Sharon later testified that Anita was so scared of Nichole that she had asked her parents to install a lock on her bedroom door — just to have a private space of her own inside her own home. When Nichole was around, Anita didn’t even want her mother visiting.
That fear was real. And it matters.
June 3, 2007: The Night That Changed Everything
Anita Knutson’s last confirmed contact with anyone came in the early morning hours of June 3, 2007. She sent text messages to a friend. Then silence. She did not show up to her shift at the Fairfield Inn on June 2. She did not answer phone calls from her family all weekend. Her mother Sharon called again and again. Nothing.
On June 4, her father Gordon Knutson made the drive to Minot. He arrived at the apartment and found her car parked outside. He knocked. No answer. The building manager unlocked the door. Gordon stepped inside.
What he found inside that bedroom is the kind of thing no father should ever have to see. His daughter was lying on the bed, face down, wrapped in a pink robe. She had been stabbed twice in the chest. The autopsy later revealed superficial cuts on her neck — the kind that come from a knife being held against a throat. She had died on the night of June 3.
The murder weapon, a small pocket knife, had been left in the bathroom sink. The bedroom window screen had been slashed and was found on the ground outside — but investigators quickly determined that nobody had actually come through that window. The fabric bins sitting below it were completely undisturbed. The screen had been cut from the inside. Someone had tried to make the scene look like a break-in.
Nothing was stolen. Anita’s purse, her laptop, her phone, and her camera were all where she had left them.
The Investigation Begins — and Stalls
Police arrived at 5:12 p.m. on June 4. They knew immediately they were dealing with a homicide. What they did not know was who did it. The apartment had four keyholders: Anita Knutson, Nichole, the building manager, and a maintenance worker.
Nichole told investigators she had been at her parents’ farm, 20 miles away, the entire weekend. She said she had no idea anything was wrong until she was contacted by police. But when officers brought her to the apartment to check if anything had been taken, she barely reacted to the news that her roommate was dead. Within minutes, she pointed out that her iPod Nano was missing from her room.
That detail struck investigators. Her roommate had just been murdered in the bedroom next door. And she was worried about a music player.
Police worked the case hard. They eventually compiled a list of 36 potential suspects and chipped that list down, using DNA testing and interviews, all the way to five people — and ultimately focused most of their attention on Nichole.
But they could not find enough hard evidence to arrest her. The case went cold. An official cold case declaration was made by the Minot Police Department. A case file with Anita’s photo on it sat on a shelf in the investigators’ office for years — something one detective described as a constant daily reminder of a case he did not want to retire without solving.
A Family Refuses to Give Up
Anita Knutson’s family did not stop pushing. On September 22, 2015 — what would have been her 27th birthday — her family hand-delivered a petition to the Minot Police Department. Over 1,000 people had signed it. The petition demanded action. It called for the department to reach out to television investigative programs for help.
That call was answered. Cold Justice, the true crime investigative series on Oxygen, came to Minot. It was actually the show’s 100th episode. Veteran prosecutor Kelly Siegler and investigator Steve Spingola joined local detectives. They reviewed everything from scratch. Text messages. DNA. Witness accounts. The inconsistencies in Nichole’s story. A reported drunken confession she allegedly made at a party, telling a former boyfriend that she had killed Anita Knutson.
The Cold Justice team helped investigators build what they felt was enough to move forward. On March 16, 2022, fifteen years after Anita’s murder, Nichole Rice was arrested at her workplace on Minot Air Force Base and charged with Class AA felony murder. Bond was set at $120,000 cash.
The Trial: Three Weeks in Grand Forks
The trial was moved from Minot to Grand Forks because of all the media attention. It began on March 18, 2025 — nearly eighteen years after the murder.
More than 20 witnesses testified over seven days. The prosecution presented a picture of a relationship that had curdled from friendship into something dangerous. They showed the threatening texts. They brought forward Nichole’s coworker, who described her as angry with Anita Knutson on a daily basis. They presented Kristina Holler, a woman who said that at a party in 2008, Nichole had confessed — she said she and Anita had argued over an alarm clock and she stabbed her. Nichole’s aunt testified that just one month after the murder, Nichole had referred to Anita in words too harsh to repeat here — and said she deserved to die.
The defense fought back hard. They argued Nichole had an alibi at her parents’ farm. They said the investigation had been sloppy, that the real killer might have been someone else entirely — including a man named Devin Hall, who had been spotted sprinting away from the apartment building on the morning of the murder.
The prosecution’s biggest problem was physical evidence. There was none directly linking Nichole to the crime. DNA found at the scene was too degraded to be conclusive. The entire case rested on witnesses, behavior patterns, and inconsistencies in Nichole’s story.
On March 26, 2025, after roughly five and a half hours of deliberation across two days, the jury delivered its verdict.
Not guilty.
The Verdict and Its Aftermath
When those words were read aloud in the Grand Forks County courthouse, Nichole’s family erupted in tears and celebration. Anita Knutson’s family walked out of the room.
Her sister Anna Knutson-Toedter released a statement that was quiet, dignified, and heartbreaking: “I spent the last week reliving some of the hardest parts of the last 18 years of my life, and in those 18 years, one thing I’ve learned is that a not guilty verdict does not mean innocence.”
Because of double jeopardy laws, Nichole Rice cannot be charged for Anita’s murder again. The Minot Police Department acknowledged that the case is now effectively cold. Investigators said they remain open to any new credible information but have no active leads.
Anita’s killer has never been convicted. As of 2026, no one has been held legally accountable for her death.
A Family That Has Endured the Unimaginable
The Knutson family’s grief did not begin and end with Anita Knutson. Her sister Patti Knutson had passed away before Anita. Her brother Daniel, who was present at a baseball game the day their father discovered Anita’s body, was never the same after losing her. In 2013, Daniel died by suicide. His sister Anna has said publicly that losing Anita also took Daniel from them that same day — it just took six years for the full damage to show itself.
Gordon and Sharon have now lost three children. They still live in Butte, North Dakota. By all accounts, they spend their time surrounded by the family members who remain, holding tight to the people they still have.
In honor of both Anita and Daniel, the family established the Anita and Daniel Knutson Memorial Scholarship Fund, ensuring that their names and their legacy continue to lift others.
How the World Remembers Anita Knutson
Near the intersection of Highway 83 south of Minot, a billboard honoring Anita still stands. Faded pink ribbons have been tied in the community she lived in. Dateline NBC covered her case twice — first in 2015 with a digital feature, and again on May 2, 2025, with a two-hour special called Murder in Minot. The episode also aired on Oxygen’s Dateline: Unforgettable.
Several hundred people attended her memorial service at Oak Valley Lutheran Church in Velva in June 2007. The crowd was so large that people spilled into the gymnasium and watched through a television monitor. She was buried at Butte Cemetery in Butte, North Dakota.
She was 18 years old. She wanted to teach children. She played the violin. She published a book at thirteen. She called her mother every day.
She deserved so much more time.
Final Words
Some stories end with justice. This one does not — at least not yet. Anita Knutson’s murder remains one of the most haunting unresolved cases in North Dakota’s history. A family lost a daughter, a sister, a future teacher. A community lost a girl who made it brighter just by being there. An eighteen-year investigation produced a trial that ended with no conviction.
What remains is her memory. Her scholarship fund. Those pink ribbons. Her sister’s voice, still speaking her name out loud so the world does not forget.
Whoever took Anita’s life on that June night in 2007 has never stood before a judge and been held responsible. That is a wound that does not close. But the love that surrounds Anita’s story — from her parents, her sister, her friends, and the strangers who signed that petition — proves that she mattered. She still does.
Read Next: Evelyn Melendez
FAQ: Anita Knutson
1. Who was Anita Knutson?
Anita was an 18-year-old freshman at Minot State University in North Dakota who was studying to become an elementary school teacher. She was adopted, loved her family deeply, and had a bright, full personality.
2. When and where was Anita Knutson born?
She was born on September 22, 1988, in Orange County, California. She was adopted at five months old by Gordon and Sharon Knutson.
3. When was Anita Knutson murdered?
She was killed on the night of June 3, 2007. Her father found her body on June 4, 2007.
4. How was Anita Knutson killed?
She was stabbed twice in the chest. The murder weapon — a small pocket knife — was left in the bathroom sink. Her bedroom window screen had been cut to make it appear someone had broken in.
5. Where did Anita Knutson live when she died?
She lived in a small apartment at 2420 4th Street NW, Apartment 5, in Minot, North Dakota, near Minot State University.
6. Who was Nichole Rice?
Nichole Rice (formerly Nichole Thomas) was Anita’s college roommate and a girl she had known from their shared hometown. She was the primary suspect in Anita’s murder.
7. Was Nichole Rice convicted?
No. Nichole Rice was arrested in March 2022 and stood trial in March 2025. The jury found her not guilty on March 26, 2025. She cannot be tried again for this crime.
8. What happened to the case after the not guilty verdict?
The Minot Police Department stated the case is effectively cold again. No active suspects exist. Police say they remain open to new credible information.
9. What role did Cold Justice play in the case?
The TV investigative show came to Minot in 2022 and worked with local detectives. Their involvement helped gather enough information that led to Nichole Rice’s arrest.
10. What was the evidence against Nichole Rice?
Prosecutors relied on witness testimony about threatening texts, a reportedly drunken confession overheard at a party, inconsistencies in Nichole’s alibi, and her odd behavior after the murder. There was no conclusive physical evidence tying her to the crime.
11. Who found Anita Knutson’s body?
Her father, Gordon Knutson, found her after driving to Minot when the family couldn’t reach her for a full weekend.
12. What happened to Anita’s brother Daniel?
Daniel Knutson struggled deeply with the loss of his sister. He died by suicide in 2013. His sister Anna has said Anita’s murder also effectively took Daniel from them.
13. Did Anita Knutson’s family set up any memorial in her name?
Yes. The family established the Anita and Daniel Knutson Memorial Scholarship Fund in memory of both Anita and Daniel.
14. Did Dateline NBC cover Anita Knutson’s case?
Yes — twice. First in a 2015 digital cold case spotlight, and again with a two-hour episode called Murder in Minot that aired on May 2, 2025.
15. Is Anita Knutson’s case still open?
As of 2026, the case has no active suspects and no convictions. The Minot Police Department says it remains open to new information but has exhausted its current leads.
For more in-depth life stories, visit Standard Magazine.
